SDG'sForAll: Uzbekistan Shows the Way for Dealing with Cultural Legacy

HOW TO BECOME A FRIEND OF THE WORLD SOCIETY?

SDG'sForAll: Uzbekistan Shows the Way for Dealing with Cultural Legacy

Cultural legacies, with their inevitable potential for controversies compounded by competing claims between contending nations, can be fraught affairs. Disputes over art works and artefacts of one country being found in another are legion. The UNESCO convention, which mandates return of illegally acquired objects to country of origin when provenance is established beyond doubt, is actually an acknowledgement that disputes are bound to persist and, therefore, require a basis to be addressed.

 

Although there are numerous instances where countries have resolved disputes over cultural objects in an amicable manner, many a long-running controversial case remains unresolved. One of the best-known cases is that of India’s fabled Kohinoor diamond.

 

Taken away by Persia’s Nadir Shah and brought back by the Sikh ruler Maharaja Ranjit Singh, under British duress, his son Duleep Singh “presented” it to Queen Victoria in the 19th century. Britain claims ownership saying it was a gift. This is disputed by four other claimants, namely, India, Pakistan, Iran and Afghanistan.

 

In sharp contrast to such running feuds, which periodically make headlines with a new twist or turn, Uzbekistan’s initiative to use cultural legacy as the path to dialogue between peoples and countries is truly ground-breaking. Nearly 220 international scientists, scholars, experts and museum heads – including 120 from at least 15 countries -- gathered for an International Scientific Congress on Cultural Legacy held over two days in the Uzbek capital of Tashkent and its ancient city Samarkand.

 

Supported by the UNESCO, ICOMOS (International Council for the Preservation of Monuments and Sites) and Germany’s Konrad Adenaur Foundation, the Congress’ agenda was to discuss ways and means of reinforcing cultural legacy as the basis for dialogues between nations.

 

Such conversations would require in-depth study, research and documentation of any one country’s legacy in other countries; and, the process itself would mean dialogue, cooperation and wider popularisation of the material and artistic culture of the countries involved. It was resolved to make the Congress an annual event, and a permanent Scientific Committee has been set up for this purpose. A number of reports and papers – on various studies of Uzbek material and artistic objects, traditions and practices in various countries – presented at the Congress are to be published.

 

In pursuance of the objective of cross-cultural dialogues, Uzbekistan has brought out 10 volumes, and several short films, on the Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in the Collections of the World. These excellent volumes in Uzbek, Russian and English on Uzbek collections, including in leading museums, in Russia, North America and Australia have been authored by well-known art historians, Orientalists, musicologists, archaeologists, curators and scientists. They are packed with visuals and comprise rich material hitherto not published in one place, said a delegate to the Congress. Almost all the delegates this writer spoke to were fulsome in their praise of the publications and their usefulness; which would, doubtless, encourage the continuation of the projects to bring out more book albums and films.

 

“I am impressed by the quality of their publications on heritage. As it is impossible to return objects from museums and collections in the world to the country of origin for a variety of reasons, the book project gave Uzbekistan an active role to engage with their heritage,” Dr Christoph Rauch, Director of the Oriental Department at Germany’s Prussian State Library in Berlin, told this author. In fact, many delegates said that it was a good idea which other countries could emulate.

 

Alexander Wilhelm, university lecturer and publisher working out of Spain and Germany welcomes the fact that the project of publishing albums would be continued. “I am a publishing man. So, in my opinion, publishing is fundamentally a good thing. To present information about peoples, their way of life and legacy, and cultural achievements is a necessary step to initiate and enlarge mutual understanding. And, it can help to prevent conflicts.”

 

Dr B R Mani, Director-General of India’s National Museum in New Delhi, told IDN that the Congress was a focused and purposeful exercise. Perhaps, no other country has done a worldwide survey of objects from their culture as Uzbekistan has done in a short period preceding the Congress. “What Uzbekistan has done is a good idea. It should be done by other countries also. I wish India, too, would do something on these lines. After all, there are tens of thousands of material and artistic objects from India in other countries,” Dr Mani said.

 

He felt a survey followed by reports and publications of objects and their locations are more important than the question of to which country these belong and the attempts to retrieve them. “This Congress and the thinking it has set in trend are not about securing the return of heritage objects, although there are people and countries that want it back,” Dr Mani said.

 

An expert from Central Europe said once the tendency to accept cultural legacies as common heritage of humanity, regardless of borders, gains ground, more countries would be open to sharing what is in their possession. “The secrecy surrounding some of the prized objects and their origin will also go.”

 

A delegate from the UK, who did not wish to be identified, said that the desire for wanting objects back, at least in some cases, belongs to a mindset of “outdated nationalism”. He felt that in a globalised world, it would be more appropriate to treat cultural legacy as “common heritage of humanity” and commit to allowing universal access. This led to an animated discussion, off the record, among a select group of experts on the merits of letting the objects remain where they are vis-à-vis the urge to ensure that it goes back to its native cultural habitat.

 

Dr Rauch observed that nations are a relatively young idea, which is already challenged in many parts of the world. “I don’t think heritage belongs to certain nations, as cultural borders are not identical with borders of modern states.”

 

Publisher Wilhelm, who made a presentation at the Congress, is optimistic about the avenues opened up by the event and exchanges. He is convinced that ‘Cultural Legacy’ is a very good platform for dialogue. “Getting to know each other is the best path to mutual understanding. Presenting one’s own past and achievements – with flaws and all -- helps to better understand different cultures. The unknown is always suspicious, if not ‘dangerous’. If I get to know my neighbours, both near and distant ones, fear disappears and understanding grows.”

 

He said that the Congress enabled participants to know Uzbekistan better. This understanding has created channels for even more communication of the Uzbek legacy to the world. The Congress, he said, has speeded up existing – and, even started new -- scientific projects, which is good: more knowledge is always an advantage and reduces the danger of misunderstanding.

 

The effort is also expected to boost tourism, especially heritage and cultural tourism. Dr Rauch said that one of the main aims of the Congress is surely to promote Uzbekistan as a world tourism destination. “Uzbekistan is a young state and they need such big congresses also for strengthening their identity,” Dr Rauch pointed out.

 

Another historian, who wants to remain anonymous, endorsed this viewpoint, adding that after the break-up of the Soviet Union, Uzbekistan and Russia seem to enjoy a “comfortable relationship” and a “healthy equilibrium” which has not made cultural legacy a contentious issue with potential for conflict – as, added another participant, has been the case between many independent developing countries and their former colonial rulers.

 

Wilhem says there are risks though, because cultural legacy is also a fraught issue. The same legacy claimed by different cultures is potentially dangerous. “Some historical events are seen differently by different people. That´s why, I think, it is a good idea to stick to the ‘cultural side’ and exclude potentially dangerous political-historical events,” he added.

 

As K Rahman, Assistant Curator of Arabic Manuscript in India’s National Museum, observed in his feedback to the Congress: This seminar was a platform for scholars and experts from all over the world to share their knowledge and expertise with respect to the Uzbek legacy, highlighting its oral, visual and literary culture. The experience and exchanges are bound to trigger new paths of collaboration that may not be limited to Uzbekistan’s cultural legacy but extends to encompassing other peoples and cultures.

 

*Shastri Ramachandaran is a senior editor of IDN-INPS and independent commentator on regional and global affairs based in New Delhi. He travelled to Tashkent and Samarkand for the International Congress on the Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan at the invitation of The National Association of Electronic Mass Media of Uzbekistan. [IDN-InDepthNews – 23 May 2017]

 

https://www.sdgsforall.net/index.php/goal-4/347-uzbekistan-shows-the-way-for-dealing-with-cultural-legacy

"Mirajnama" at the Court of Louis XIV

"Mirajnama" at the Court of Louis XIV

The National Library of France has a rich history, beginning with its establishment as the royal library. An important milestone in its development was the accumulation of manuscripts from Central Asia, which contributed to the expansion of knowledge about Eastern culture and literature. One of the key acquisitions was the famous manuscript "Mirajnama," which arrived in Paris in the 17th century. Read here about how this ancient manuscript came into the hands of the Musketeers’ ruler, Louis XIV.

Read more...
Did Prokudin-Gorsky work as a tax collector in Turkestan?

Did Prokudin-Gorsky work as a tax collector in Turkestan?

Pioneer of color photography in the Russian Empire, author of hundreds of photographs of Turkestan and the famous photograph of the Emir of Bukhara, Prokudin-Gorsky made a significant contribution to the cultural heritage of both Uzbekistan and the world. His works are stored in the Library of Congress in the USA, and exhibitions are held worldwide. But was photography his primary occupation, or were the photographs merely a hobby while he earned his living as a tax collector in Turkestan, a role often despised in the regions of the Russian Empire? Let's explore this here.

Read more...
Suzani, bringing happiness to collectors in the USA

Suzani, bringing happiness to collectors in the USA

Unique suzanis from the Bukhara Emirate of the 18th century, featuring large medallions and inscriptions by Karman (Kermine), evoke a sense of happiness in the hearts of Bruce and Olive Baganz, who cherish them in their collection in the USA.

Read more...
The Vatican Library is planning to engage WOSCU in the study of its archives

The Vatican Library is planning to engage WOSCU in the study of its archives

The Prefect (General Director) of the Vatican Apostolic Library, Mauro Mantovani, has not ruled out the possibility of close collaboration with WOSCU and the involvement of orientalists from the World Society in studying the archives of one of the unique libraries in the world.

Read more...
Scientists have proposed that the Center for Islamic Civilization (CIC) and WOSCU study the "contract of Muhammad with the jinn" and the robe of the Quran.

Scientists have proposed that the Center for Islamic Civilization (CIC) and WOSCU study the "contract of Muhammad with the jinn" and the robe of the Quran.

During the VIII Congress of WOSCU, dedicated to the activities of the Center for Islamic Civilization, Deputy Director for Research at the State Museum of the History of Religion, Ekaterina Teryukova, presented a report on a collaborative research project titled "Religious and Domestic Cult Objects from Uzbekistan in the Collection of the Museum of the History of Religion: History, Attribution, Restoration," in collaboration with museum researcher Irina Osmanova.

Read more...
Karakalpak jewelry in the collection of the Russian Ethnographic Museum

Karakalpak jewelry in the collection of the Russian Ethnographic Museum

Karakalpak jewelry, presented in the Russian Ethnographic Museum, reflects the rich cultural tradition and artistic mastery of this people. Among them, various types of women's pectoral jewelry, earrings, rings and bracelets stand out, each of which carries unique symbolism and meaning.

Read more...
Alexander the Great and the Riddle of the Cup of Jamshid

Alexander the Great and the Riddle of the Cup of Jamshid

The miniature "Seven Sages," dated around 1590, serves as an intriguing example of the interaction between various cultures and traditions in the art of that time. It likely depicts Iskandar (Alexander the Great) surrounded by seven philosophers, who may symbolize the wisdom and knowledge of different peoples studying the Cup of Jamshid.

Read more...
Ruidjo - the mystery of family happiness

Ruidjo - the mystery of family happiness

Ruidjo is not just an element of textile, but a symbol of tradition and culture, which plays an important role in the life of newlyweds. An embroidered sheet, sewn from four strips of cotton fabric, is a work of art in which every detail matters.

Read more...
Chinese monk inspired Japanese to study Central Asia

Chinese monk inspired Japanese to study Central Asia

In the 7th century, the Chinese monk Xuanzang traveled through Central Asia to India in search of Buddhist sutras, writing about it in his travel notes “Journey to the Western Region.” Hundreds of years later, it was this work that inspired Japanese explorers in the 19th and 20th centuries to study the region.

Read more...
The National Library of Uzbekistan - a journey of one and a half centuries

The National Library of Uzbekistan - a journey of one and a half centuries

For more than 150 years of its existence, the National Library of Uzbekistan named after Alisher Navoi has gone through an amazing and difficult path of development, associated with the search and study of unique manuscripts, authorship of outstanding personalities of different eras. In this video, we will be introduced to the history of the remarkable library and its impressive collection.

Read more...
How did costume influence Tamara Khanum’s career?

How did costume influence Tamara Khanum’s career?

Tamara Khanum, a famous Uzbek actress and dancer, left a bright mark in the history of Uzbek art. Her concert costume, kept in the State Historical Museum, is not only an element of her stage image, but also a symbol of the cultural heritage of Uzbekistan.

Read more...
Kova is an ancient center of Buddhist culture

Kova is an ancient center of Buddhist culture

Archaeological excavations on the outskirts of the city of Kuva have uncovered the remains of a Buddhist temple dating back to the 7th century. This discovery proves that Kuva became an important center of religious life in its time.

Read more...
Handwritten monuments of Turkish history in Tashkent's Beruni Institute

Handwritten monuments of Turkish history in Tashkent's Beruni Institute

The history of Turkey in the collection of the Abu Rayhan Beruni Institute of Oriental Studies is represented by six manuscripts, including "Tarikh" ("History") and "Misbah al-sari wa nuzhat al-kari" ("Lamp for the Traveler and Consolation for the Reader"). These works present important milestones in the history of the Ottoman Empire.

Read more...
Hadiths and wishes on ceramic dishes

Hadiths and wishes on ceramic dishes

Glazed ceramics decor of the 10th-12th centuries. Excellently reflect the significant changes that came to the culet and art of the Central Asian region as a result of the spread of Islam. Completely new characteristics of Islamic art.

Read more...
The book under the microscope: Where are our books printed?

The book under the microscope: Where are our books printed?

Read more...
The book under the microscope: book printing

The book under the microscope: book printing

Read more...
The Taliq script: "suspended" and official

The Taliq script: "suspended" and official

Read more...
The book under the microscope: Luxury squared

The book under the microscope: Luxury squared

Read more...
How to meet the Emir? Or the whole truth about Amir Timur's favorite musical instrument.

How to meet the Emir? Or the whole truth about Amir Timur's favorite musical instrument.

Read more...
How much money did Navoi have?

How much money did Navoi have?

Read more...
Book under the microscope: What does the book consist of?

Book under the microscope: What does the book consist of?

Read more...
What was Uzbekistan like in the middle of the 19th century? Everyone will have a unique chance to see exclusive rare pictures of cities, palaces and customs

What was Uzbekistan like in the middle of the 19th century? Everyone will have a unique chance to see exclusive rare pictures of cities, palaces and customs

Read more...
The book under the microscope: Paints and Gilding

The book under the microscope: Paints and Gilding

Read more...
Book under the microscope: Paper

Book under the microscope: Paper

Read more...
AISAN STYLE SCRUBBLEDUB! LET’S CALL THE JUGS CORRECTLY!

AISAN STYLE SCRUBBLEDUB! LET’S CALL THE JUGS CORRECTLY!

Read more...
Health Secrets of AVICENNA

Health Secrets of AVICENNA

Read more...
BLUEBIRD OF HAPPINESS ON THE BOTTOM OF A PIALA. FIND OUT IF THERE ARE ANY MUSEUM RARITIES IN YOUR HOUSE?

BLUEBIRD OF HAPPINESS ON THE BOTTOM OF A PIALA. FIND OUT IF THERE ARE ANY MUSEUM RARITIES IN YOUR HOUSE?

Read more...
How were jewelers able to masterfully create cheap adornments which looked expensive?

How were jewelers able to masterfully create cheap adornments which looked expensive?

Read more...
Price for fabrics in medieval Uzbekistan: by selling only one curtain, it was possible to pay the entire land tax

Price for fabrics in medieval Uzbekistan: by selling only one curtain, it was possible to pay the entire land tax

Read more...
How was water sanctified and used to treat all diseases in Uzbekistan since ancient times?

How was water sanctified and used to treat all diseases in Uzbekistan since ancient times?

Read more...
Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in World Collections project has published 60 volumes of book-albums

Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in World Collections project has published 60 volumes of book-albums

Read more...
Sara Noshadi: UNESCO is pleased to see Uzbekistan's efforts to preserve its cultural heritage

Sara Noshadi: UNESCO is pleased to see Uzbekistan's efforts to preserve its cultural heritage

Read more...
The 6th International Congress of the World Society Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan - the Foundation of a New Renaissance will take place in Uzbekistan

The 6th International Congress of the World Society Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan - the Foundation of a New Renaissance will take place in Uzbekistan

Read more...
A book devoted to the unique Uzbek collection from the Malaysian Al-Bukhari Foundation to be presented in Uzbekistan

A book devoted to the unique Uzbek collection from the Malaysian Al-Bukhari Foundation to be presented in Uzbekistan

Read more...
Book revealing main stages in cinema development to be published in Uzbekistan

Book revealing main stages in cinema development to be published in Uzbekistan

Read more...
Uzbekistan presents a book dedicated to the Uzbek Legacy in the museums of the Republic of Tatarstan

Uzbekistan presents a book dedicated to the Uzbek Legacy in the museums of the Republic of Tatarstan

Read more...
35 volumes of Cultural Heritage of Uzbekistan in World Collections series presented to Uzbek Academy of Sciences

35 volumes of Cultural Heritage of Uzbekistan in World Collections series presented to Uzbek Academy of Sciences

Read more...
Tanzilya Narbayeva, the President of the Senate of Uzbekistan presented the books of the project Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in the World Collections

Tanzilya Narbayeva, the President of the Senate of Uzbekistan presented the books of the project Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in the World Collections

Read more...
Masterpieces of cultural legacy of Uzbekistan described in 50 albums

Masterpieces of cultural legacy of Uzbekistan described in 50 albums

Read more...
Anniversary Congress of the World Society has summed up the results

Anniversary Congress of the World Society has summed up the results

Read more...
Anniversary Congress of the World Society has summed up the results

Anniversary Congress of the World Society has summed up the results

Read more...
Appeal of participants of the 5th international congress  "The cultural legacy of Uzbekistan: the foundation of a new renaissance" to the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan Shavkat Mirziyoyev

Appeal of participants of the 5th international congress "The cultural legacy of Uzbekistan: the foundation of a new renaissance" to the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan Shavkat Mirziyoyev

Read more...
Events of the new Cultural Heritage Week announced

Events of the new Cultural Heritage Week announced

Read more...
A volume on artifacts of the cultural legacy of Uzbekistan from private collections in the USA and Canada has been published

A volume on artifacts of the cultural legacy of Uzbekistan from private collections in the USA and Canada has been published

Read more...
Aziz Abduhakimov: project "Cultural legacy of Uzbekistan" is a unique initiative

Aziz Abduhakimov: project "Cultural legacy of Uzbekistan" is a unique initiative

Read more...
The exhibition "Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan" opened in the Museum of the History of the Temurids

The exhibition "Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan" opened in the Museum of the History of the Temurids

Read more...
Firdavs Abdukhalikov, "We must educate our youth"

Firdavs Abdukhalikov, "We must educate our youth"

Read more...
The Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan project is preparing a grand event

The Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan project is preparing a grand event

Read more...
Ernesto Ramirez: Uzbekistan's work on the study of cultural heritage is an example for many countries

Ernesto Ramirez: Uzbekistan's work on the study of cultural heritage is an example for many countries

Read more...
The cultural legacy of Uzbekistan was presented in Paris

The cultural legacy of Uzbekistan was presented in Paris

Read more...
Dialogue of Cultures: the Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan presented in Delhi

Dialogue of Cultures: the Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan presented in Delhi

Read more...
Presentation of a series of books on the cultural heritage of Uzbekistan was held in Delhi

Presentation of a series of books on the cultural heritage of Uzbekistan was held in Delhi

Read more...
The author of the project "Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in World Collections" was awarded the "Mekhnat Shukhrati" Order

The author of the project "Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in World Collections" was awarded the "Mekhnat Shukhrati" Order

Read more...
Silk ikats from Bukhara in the center of St. Petersburg

Silk ikats from Bukhara in the center of St. Petersburg

Read more...
The Kultura TV Channel about the Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in St. Petersburg

The Kultura TV Channel about the Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in St. Petersburg

Read more...
International Congress in St. Petersburg is ready to open

International Congress in St. Petersburg is ready to open

Read more...
An exhibition of manuscripts by Alisher Navoi was held in the Russian Library

An exhibition of manuscripts by Alisher Navoi was held in the Russian Library

Read more...
The museum of the history of religion in St. Petersburg is preparing an exhibition dedicated to Uzbekistan

The museum of the history of religion in St. Petersburg is preparing an exhibition dedicated to Uzbekistan

Read more...
What kind of congress will the Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in St. Petersburg be

What kind of congress will the Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in St. Petersburg be

Read more...
A virtual girl will dance in the St. Petersburg museum in honor of the opening of the congress

A virtual girl will dance in the St. Petersburg museum in honor of the opening of the congress

Read more...
The unique robe of the emir of Bukhara will be seen by the participants of the congress in St. Petersburg

The unique robe of the emir of Bukhara will be seen by the participants of the congress in St. Petersburg

Read more...
Cultural legacy of Uzbekistan in German collections will be presented at the congress

Cultural legacy of Uzbekistan in German collections will be presented at the congress

Read more...
Kamola Akilova about the congress: this is a great event for world culture

Kamola Akilova about the congress: this is a great event for world culture

Read more...
Elmira Gul on new albums from the cultural legacy of Uzbekistan series

Elmira Gul on new albums from the cultural legacy of Uzbekistan series

Read more...
On April 18, 2018, the International Round Table “Cultural Heritage of Uzbekistan in the UK Collections” was held at the Embassy of the Republic of Uzbekistan in London.

On April 18, 2018, the International Round Table “Cultural Heritage of Uzbekistan in the UK Collections” was held at the Embassy of the Republic of Uzbekistan in London.

Read more...
Navoi's lifetime manuscripts stored abroad can be seen in Uzbekistan

Navoi's lifetime manuscripts stored abroad can be seen in Uzbekistan

Read more...
The project "Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan" will present a Roadmap

The project "Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan" will present a Roadmap

Read more...
A forum on the great heritage of the past is being held in Tashkent

A forum on the great heritage of the past is being held in Tashkent

Read more...
Rtveladze: the whole world should know about the cultural legacy of Uzbekistan

Rtveladze: the whole world should know about the cultural legacy of Uzbekistan

Read more...
The Russian Academy of Sciences will hand over copies of ancient manuscripts to Uzbekistan

The Russian Academy of Sciences will hand over copies of ancient manuscripts to Uzbekistan

Read more...
Tashkent will host the forum "Crossroads of Times: the great legacy of the past - the basis of an enlightened future"

Tashkent will host the forum "Crossroads of Times: the great legacy of the past - the basis of an enlightened future"

Read more...
Russian libraries and museums will receive a catalog of Uzbekistan's cultural legacy

Russian libraries and museums will receive a catalog of Uzbekistan's cultural legacy

Read more...
"Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan" gathered world scientists in Tashkent and Samarkand

"Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan" gathered world scientists in Tashkent and Samarkand

Read more...
The World Scientific Society aimed at studying the cultural legacy of Uzbekistan established

The World Scientific Society aimed at studying the cultural legacy of Uzbekistan established

Read more...
A World scientific society has been established to study the cultural legacy of Uzbekistan

A World scientific society has been established to study the cultural legacy of Uzbekistan

Read more...
The project "Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in world collections" was presented in Tashkent

The project "Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in world collections" was presented in Tashkent

Read more...
The project Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in the World Collections presented in the capital

The project Cultural Legacy of Uzbekistan in the World Collections presented in the capital

Read more...
Cultural legacy of Uzbekistan the way to dialogue between peoples and countries” may 15–16, 2017 Tashkent / Samarkand

Cultural legacy of Uzbekistan the way to dialogue between peoples and countries” may 15–16, 2017 Tashkent / Samarkand

Read more...
A Path to a Dialogue Between Nations and Countries international congress

A Path to a Dialogue Between Nations and Countries international congress

Read more...

Other news